Fifty-seven years ago today, Clint Eastwood did something few fans of his hard-edged Westerns would have expected: he sang. The actor traded his familiar gunslinger persona for Paint Your Wagon, a sprawling musical comedy that premiered October 15, 1969.
Instead of playing another mysterious gunfighter, Eastwood starred alongside Lee Marvin and Jean Seberg in a gold rush adventure involving romance, mining, and an unusual love triangle. The film gave audiences a completely different side of the rising Hollywood star.
Next: John Wayne’s 1933 Western Classic Tried to Make Him a Singing Cowboy
Clint Eastwood Traded Gunfights for Love Songs
According to the American Film Institute, Eastwood played Pardner, a prospector who becomes involved with Marvin’s Ben Rumson and Seberg’s Elizabeth in a California mining settlement called No Name City.
The movie also featured Eastwood singing “I Talk to the Trees,” a considerable departure from the stoic characters he portrayed in Sergio Leone’s Westerns.
The AFI’s song credits include “The First Thing You Know,” “A Million Miles Away Behind the Door,” “The Gospel of No Name City,” “Best Things” and “Gold Fever.”
They also list “I’m on My Way,” “I Still See Elisa,” “Hand Me Down that Can o’ Beans,” “They Call the Wind Maria,” “I Talk to the Trees,” “There’s A Coach Comin’ In,” “Whoop-Ti-Ay,” and “Wandrin’ Star.”
Next: 1976 Classic, Turned Down by Clint Eastwood, Named Among John Wayne’s Best Westerns of All Time
Hollywood’s Ambitious Western Didn’t Deliver
The film was an expensive gamble. Directed by Joshua Logan and adapted from the 1951 stage musical, Paint Your Wagon combined elaborate musical numbers with a frontier story that was far removed from Eastwood’s earlier hits.
AFI reports that Paramount supported the release with a $2 million promotional campaign and planned presentations in “70mm, six-track stereo in 46 theaters” by year’s end.
But the spectacle didn’t guarantee success. AFI describes the critical response as mixed and ticket sales as disappointing. Paramount president Frank Yablans later estimated the film would gross $14 million.
Next: 66 Years Later: 1960 Steve McQueen Classic, Once Dismissed by Critics, Named Among Greatest Westerns
The Western That Broke Eastwood’s Familiar Formula
Despite its troubled reception, Paint Your Wagon received an Academy Award nomination for Nelson Riddle’s musical score.
More than five decades later, Paint Your Wagon holds a 45% critics’ score on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 20 reviews, compared with a more favorable 68% audience score from more than 5,000 ratings.
The film remains a revealing detour in Eastwood’s career. While audiences increasingly associated him with dangerous, tight-lipped antiheroes, this production asked him to embrace comedy, romance, and music.
Related: 1968 Classic, Named ‘Best Western Movie of All Time,’ Was Turned Down by Clint Eastwood
